I emailed all three, and choice number two and three were both open. Choice one (our first choice) had a room open for all but three of the nights. I emailed the owner, and then he called me and offered me a different room for the first three nights (more expensive room) and the original room the rest of the time, for the same cost. And one night free.
I gave him a deposit right then.
We are staying at Hacienda Paraiso de La Paz Inn, and I will review it after we return.
In summary:
- Look ahead of time for places to stay in the destinations you are considering.
- Ask the owner if it doesn't seem to be working out.
- Be willing to pay a deposit right away to seal a good deal.
Target price for this trip: two weeks, $4500 for two people.